LFA News and Publications


Divided House kills HB 391

posted on
Divided House kills HB 391

Divided House kills HB 391

By Ryan Noonan / LSU Manship School News Service

BATON ROUGE — The House rejected a hotly debated bill Tuesday that would have opened up closed waters for public access and navigation.

HB 391, which failed 58-38, essentially would have allowed recreational fishermen to fish in some privately owned waters and waterways without fear of legal consequences.

After spending two hours of debate on an unusually large number of amendments, it became clear that representatives were too divided on the issue.

Some of the most prominent concerns included the ways people could build structures to block waterways, the liability of property owners and even how to define “running waters.”

Amendments addressing all of these issues were considered, a few which were adopted. However, the bill’s sponsor, Rep. J. Kevin Pearson, R-Slidell, complained that a number of the amendments were just “poison pills” to help kill the bill.

Others, like Rep. Barry Ivey, R-Central, felt the bill was simply too intrusive on landowners.

Essentially, the private waters that would have been affected by the bill were those that are connected to state waters or waterways subject to coastal tide activity.

This would have been significant, as there are a large number of coastal marshes and swamps in the state that meet these requirements and are privately owned.

While the land underneath and surrounding the water can be owned privately, the water itself — as well as its aquatic life — is classified as state property.

However, trespassing laws have allowed private owners to file charges against boaters and anglers accessing the property. Pearson said his primary concern in proposing the bill was to eliminate this risk for recreational fishermen.

“This bill was never, ever about access to any land,” said Pearson. “We are trying to allow Louisiana, which once was called the sportsman's paradise, to remain the sportsman’s paradise.

“We can’t remain the sportsman's paradise when you have someone fishing in southern Louisiana and getting a ticket for trespassing on property that he doesn’t even know is private.”

Pearson also said he had reached out to landowners about the bill but had received less-than-enthusiastic responses from them.

“I have not had any assistance there, it’s just, ‘We’re going to kill the bill,’ ” he said.

While the public would have been able to access the waterways, the ownership of the land would not have been affected. Owners also would have retained limited liability if their properties were used by others for recreational purposes.

A previous version of the bill allowed for an exemption from the law in areas in which obstacles impeding navigation were constructed by a private landowner before March. That was amended to require a permit from the Department of Natural Resources before the bill was killed.

According to Louisiana Sportsman magazine, B.A.S.S., a prominent fishing organization, had said it would stop hosting tournaments in Louisiana tidewaters that appeared to be public waterways if recreational fishermen were at risk of arrest.

| Categories: LFA News | Tags: | View Count: (851) | Return
News Categories

Most Popular

  • First lady of Louisiana forestry

    Early in the 20th century, the practice of forestry in America was in its infancy. Its proponents were strong-willed men with a determined focus. Women were not and would not become involved in this m...
    Read More
  • The State of Louisiana’s Forests

    As we celebrate Arbor Day in Louisiana, we think it’s a good time to catch up on the “State of the Forest.” Trees cover half of our state and forests are the single greatest land use in Louisiana. ...
    Read More
  • Reward offered to nab perpetrator who destroyed woods equipment in LaSalle Parish

    A reward of up to $7,000 has been offered for information leading to the arrest and conviction of the person or people who vandalized and destroyed a LaSalle Parish logger's equipment, according to th...
    Read More
  • Louisiana Logger Magazine - April 2015

    Louisiana Logger - April 2015: Someone may be watching you!; Bonner Logging has husband and wife duo; OSHA Alliance with loggers works to improve safety; It’s wild turkey season in the woods of Louis...
    Read More
  • 2014 LFA Annual Report

    President Dave Cupp's message, comparative budgets, 2015 LFA Board list, highlights from 2014, news including emerald ash borer, billboards, Kisatchie quarter and Martco's planned OSB mill.
    Read More
  • Arbor Day seedling giveaway

    The Louisiana Forestry Association (LFA) is giving away 1000 trees on Wednesday, Jan. 23 for Arbor Day. The giveaway will include red maple, baldcypress, nuttall oak, and Eastern redbud. The tree give...
    Read More